Elf on the Shelf Sugar Cookies 🎅🏼🍪 Love 'em or not, those mischievous little elves are making their seasonal return—and we’re here to make their arrival extra sweet!
Our custom Elf on the Shelf sugar cookies come in boy or girl options, as singles or in sets. Each cookie is hand decorated, heat sealed for freshness, and personalized with your child’s name.
Cookie Details:
Size: 4" x 4"
Personalized with your child’s name
Available as singles or in sets
Personalized elf note
📦 Ordering Tips:
Ordering for multiple elves? Please add each cookie/set one at a time.
Want to include a note from your elf? Add it in the options section.
Ordering for multiple families? No problem—just leave a note at checkout and we’ll package accordingly.
👨👩👧👦 Frequently Asked Elf Questions:
Whose gender should I choose? Usually your elf’s, but some prefer matching their child’s.
Will multiple elf sets look the same? That’s up to you! Just let us know in the comments. Example: Liam (B), Nate (B), Charlotte (G).
Will the message be the same as last year? Nope! We’ve got a fresh new message for 2025.
More than 3 kids? Add a box with 4 cookies, then add additional single elves in clear bags. We’ll do our best to package them as a family set.
Can I pick up before November 29th? Unfortunately, no. Pick-up begins November 28–29, with extras available after December 1 for farewell treats.
🚗 Contactless Pick-Up Info:
You’ll receive a notification when your order is ready.
Text us your order number when you arrive—we’ll bring your elves out to you.
We’ll wait while you confirm name spellings and cookie details.
Cookies are packed in discreet bags. If kids are with you, let us know and we’ll text a photo for approval before meeting you.
Food Sensitivities? We now offer a variety of cookie options to help everyone feel included in the celebration:
Sugar Cookies: Available in gluten, dairy, and/or egg friendly versions
Shortbread: Naturally egg friendly
Gingerbread: Naturally dairy friendly
Please note: While we are a bakery that uses all of these ingredients, your cookies will be produced separately to minimize cross-contamination. If you'd like your entire box allergen-friendly, please request a quote before completing your order.
